The difference between food poisoning and stomach flu comes down to how the germ reached you. Food poisoning starts with something you ate or drank. Stomach flu, which doctors call viral gastroenteritis, usually passes from one person to another, and it has nothing to do with influenza, a respiratory infection.
Here’s where it gets messy. The virus behind most stomach flu is norovirus, and the CDC calls it the most common cause of foodborne illness as well as of vomiting and diarrhea in general. So the two labels overlap, and from the bathroom floor you often can’t tell them apart. You can read some clues, though.
You can also learn which symptoms mean it’s time to call someone.
Why the two get mixed up so often
Both hit the gut, so both bring diarrhea and vomiting, with cramps and a fever on some days. Put the CDC’s page on food poisoning symptoms next to its page on norovirus and they read almost like the same document.
It helps to think of stomach flu as one kind of foodborne illness that can also travel without food. An Alaska Section of Epidemiology bulletin covering outbreaks from 2000 to 2003 lists a norovirus outbreak on a cruise ship in Whittier, and a 2001 church catering event in Anchorage where potato salad and an ill food handler were the cause. One illness spread through shared space. The other spread through shared food. Either way, the toilet got the same workout.
Timing and company: the two clues worth using
Start with the clock. Norovirus symptoms usually begin 12 to 48 hours after exposure. Food poisoning has a far wider range, because some germs work within hours and others take days. By the CDC’s figures, Salmonella runs from 6 hours to 6 days, Campylobacter 2 to 5 days, and E. coli 3 to 4 days.
So an illness that starts a few hours after a meal leans toward food. A late start proves very little, and it explains why the last thing you ate is so often the wrong suspect.
Then look around the table. If several people who shared a meal got sick at about the same time, food poisoning becomes the better bet, Baylor Scott & White notes. If the illness creeps through your household one person at a time over several days, that fits the person to person spread of a stomach virus.
Symptoms themselves help less than people expect. Bloody diarrhea and a high fever lean toward bacterial food poisoning, since the CDC lists both among signs of severe cases, while stomach flu more often brings a low-grade fever. A lean isn’t a diagnosis, though. Pinning down the exact germ takes a stool test, and WebMD says norovirus is usually diagnosed from symptoms alone.
How long each one lasts
Most healthy people shake off norovirus in 1 to 3 days. Plenty of food poisoning clears in a day or two as well, although some bacterial infections run longer.
Duration won’t settle the question, but contagion changes what you do. People with norovirus can still spread it for a few days after they feel better, and the California Department of Public Health says not to prepare food for others until at least 2 days after symptoms stop. If you cook for a household, that rule matters more than the label.
The first day looks the same either way
Fluids come first. Vomiting and diarrhea drain water and salt faster than most people realize, so take small, slow sips of water or an oral rehydration drink instead of gulping.
Sports drinks work for adults when you dilute them, because the sugar can make diarrhea worse. Clear broth gives you fluid and sodium in one cup. Once your appetite returns, go back to normal food. You don’t need a strict diet.
Medicine needs more care. Antibiotics do nothing against a stomach virus and won’t help every type of food poisoning, so a clinician should make that call. Skip anti-diarrheal pills if you have bloody diarrhea or a high fever.
When to stop waiting it out
The CDC tells people to see a doctor for any of these:
- Bloody diarrhea
- Diarrhea lasting more than 3 days
- A fever above 102°F
- Vomiting so frequent you can’t keep liquids down
- Signs of dehydration, such as very little urine, a dry mouth or dizziness when you stand
Babies, young children, older adults and people with weakened immune systems dehydrate faster, so don’t hold them to the 3 day mark. In pregnancy, the CDC says to call the doctor right away if you have a fever and feel more tired and achy than usual, because Listeria infections can harm a pregnancy.
Two sets of symptoms belong to neither illness. Double vision or drooping eyelids after eating fermented food can mean botulism, and tingling in the lips and tongue after eating shellfish can mean paralytic shellfish poisoning. Both are emergencies, so call 911.
Alaska health officials test commercially grown shellfish, but the CDC’s report on a 2011 outbreak points out that shellfish gathered for personal use is not tested. Botulism is also more common here than in most of the country, largely because of traditional fermented foods. Our post on food poisoning symptoms and Alaska risks goes deeper on both.
When the nearest clinic is a flight away
Distances in Alaska can turn a bad night into a travel problem. That’s where a video visit earns its place.
At Telemedicine Alaska, you meet a nurse practitioner by video from your phone or computer. She reviews your symptoms and medications, checks for dehydration, and tells you whether remote care fits. A visit is a flat $60, or $100 for a family consultation covering immediate blood relatives. Our services page lists what we see, and you can read more about the practice on the About Us page.
Video has limits. We can’t run stool tests or imaging, so if you need an exam or lab work, we refer you to in person care. Prescriptions are possible when appropriate, but you must be in Alaska, Arizona, Colorado or Wyoming during the visit and able to pick up medication at an Alaska pharmacy. Weighing a walk-in clinic instead? We compared the two in AFC Urgent Care vs. Telemedicine Alaska.
Cruise ships are on Baylor Scott & White’s list of places where stomach flu shows up in clusters.
If you’re packing for one, our guide to motion sickness medication for an Alaska cruise covers the other kind of queasy.
Keeping it from reaching everyone else
Wash with soap and water. Hand sanitizer works less well against some viruses, including norovirus, so treat it as a backup. Clean hard surfaces with a bleach solution or an EPA registered disinfectant, and keep a sick family member away from shared plates and utensils.